Sunday, November 6, 2016

psutil 5.0.0 is around twice as fast

OK, this is a big one. Starting from psutil 5.0.0 you can query multiple Process information around twice as fast than with previous versions (see original ticket and updated doc). It took me 7 months, 108 commits and a massive refactoring of psutil internals (here is the big commit), and I can safely say this is one of the best improvements and long standing issues which have been addressed in a major psutil release. Here goes.

The problem

Except for some cases, the way different process information are retrieved varies depending on the OS. Sometimes it requires reading a file in /proc filesystem (Linux), some other times it requires using C (Windows, BSD, OSX, SunOS), but every time it's done differently. Psutil abstracts this complexity by providing a nice high-level interface so that you, say, call Process.name() without worrying about what happens behind the curtains or on what OS you're on.

Internally, it is not rare that multiple process info (e.g. name(), ppid(), uids(), create_time()) may be fetched by using the same routine. For example, on Linux we read /proc/stat to get the process name, terminal, CPU times, creation time, status and parent PID, but only one value is returned and the others are discarded. On Linux the code below reads /proc/stat 6 times:
>>> import psutil
>>> p = psutil.Process()
>>> p.name()
>>> p.cpu_times()
>>> p.create_time()
>>> p.ppid()
>>> p.status()
>>> p.terminal()
Another example is BSD. In order to get process name, memory, CPU times and other metrics, a single sysctl() call is necessary, but again, because of how psutil used to work so far that same sysctl() call is executed every time (see here, here, and so on), one information is returned (say name()) and the rest is discarded. Not anymore.

Do it in one shot

It appears clear how the approach described above is not efficient, also considering that applications similar to top, htop, ps or glances usually collect more than one info per-process.
psutil 5.0.0 introduces a new oneshot() context manager. When used, the internal routine is executed once (in the example below on name()) and the other values are cached. The subsequent calls sharing the same internal routine (read /proc/stat, call sysctl() or whatever) will return the cached value.
With psutil 5.0.0 the code above can be rewritten like this, and on Linux it will run 2.4 times faster: 
>>> import psutil
>>> p = psutil.Process()
>>> with p.oneshot():
...     p.name()
...     p.cpu_times()
...     p.create_time()
...     p.ppid()
...     p.status()
...     p.terminal()

Implementation

One great thing about psutil design is its abstraction. It is dived in 3 "layers". The first layer is represented by the main Process class (python), which is what dictates the end-user high-level API. The second layer is the OS-specific Python module which is thin wrapper on top of the OS-specific C extension module (third layer). Because this was organized this way (modularly) the refactoring was reasonably smooth. In order to do this I first refactored those C functions collecting multiple info and grouped them in a single function (e.g. see BSD implementation). Then I wrote a decorator which enables the cache only when requested (when entering the context manager) and decorated the "grouped functions" with with it. The whole thing is enabled on request by the highest-level oneshot() context manager, which is the only thing which is exposed to the end user. Here's the decorator:
def memoize_when_activated(fun):
    """A memoize decorator which is disabled by default. It can be
    activated and deactivated on request.
    """
    @functools.wraps(fun)
    def wrapper(self):
        if not wrapper.cache_activated:
            return fun(self)
        else:
            try:
                ret = cache[fun]
            except KeyError:
                ret = cache[fun] = fun(self)
            return ret

    def cache_activate():
        """Activate cache."""
        wrapper.cache_activated = True

    def cache_deactivate():
        """Deactivate and clear cache."""
        wrapper.cache_activated = False
        cache.clear()

    cache = {}
    wrapper.cache_activated = False
    wrapper.cache_activate = cache_activate
    wrapper.cache_deactivate = cache_deactivate
    return wrapper
In order to measure the various speedups I finally wrote a benchmark script (well 2 actually) and kept tuning until I was sure the various changes made psutil actually faster. The benchmark scripts calculate the speedup you can get if you call all the "grouped" methods together (best case scenario).

Linux: +2.56x speedup

Linux process is the only pure-python implementation as (almost) all process info are gathered by reading files in the /proc filesystem. /proc files typically contain different information about the process and /proc/PID/stat and /proc/PID/status are the perfect examples. That's why on Linux we aggregate them in 3 groups. The relevant part of the Linux implementation can be seen here.

Windows: from +1.9x to +6.5x speedup

Windows is an interesting one. In normal circumstances, if we're querying a process owned by our user, we group together only process' num_threads(), num_ctx_switches() and num_handles(), getting a +1.9x speedup if we access those methods in one shot. Windows is particular though, because certain methods use a dual implementation: a "fast method" is attempted first, but if the process is owned by another user it fails with AccessDenied. In that case psutil falls back on using a second "slower" method (see here for example).
The second method is slower because it iterates over all PIDs but differently than "plain" Windows APIs it can be used to get multiple info in one shot: num threads, context switches, handles, CPU times, create time and IO counters. That is why querying processes owned by other users results in an impressive +6.5 speedup.

OSX: +1.92x speedup

On OSX we can get 2 groups of information. With sysctl() syscall we get process parent PID, uids, gids, terminal, create time, name. With proc_info() syscall we get CPU times (for PIDs owned by another user) memory metrics and ctx switches. Not bad.

BSD: +2.18x speedup

BSD was an interesting one as we gather a tons of process info just by calling sysctl() (see implementation). In a single shot we get process name, ppid, status, uids, gids, IO counters, CPU and create times, terminal and ctx switches.

SunOS: +1.37 speedup

SunOS implementation is similar to Linux implementation in that it reads files in /proc filesystem but differently from Linux this is done in C. Also in this case, we can group different metrics together (see here and here).

External links


Sunday, October 23, 2016

psutil 4.4.0 released - improved Linux memory metrics and OSX support

OK, here's another psutil release. Main highlights of this release are more accurate memory metrics on Linux and different OSX fixes. Here goes.

Linux virtual memory

This new psutil release sets a milestone regarding virtual_memory() metrics on Linux which are now calculated way more precisely (see commit). Across the years different people complained that the numbers reported by virtual_memory() were not accurate or did not match the ones reported by "free" command line utility exactly (see #862, #685, #538). As such I investigated how "available memory" is calculated on Linux and indeed psutil were doing it wrong. It turns out "free" cmdline itself, and many other similar tools, also did it wrong up until 2 years ago when somebody finally decided to accurately calculate the available system memory straight into the Linux kernel and expose this info to user-level applications. Starting from Linux kernel 3.14, a new "MemAvailable" column was added to /proc/meminfo and this is how psutil now determines available memory. Because of this both "available" and "used" memory fields returned by virtual_memory() precisely match "free" command line utility. As for older kernels (< 3.14), psutil tries to determine this value by using the same algorithm which was used in the original Linux kernel commit. Free cmdline utility source code also inspired an additional fix which prevents available memory overflowing total memory on LCX containers.

OSX fixes

For many years the OSX development of psutil occurred on a very old OSX 10.5 version, which I emulated via VirtualBox. The OS itself was a hacked version of OSX, called iDeneb. After many years I finally managed to get access to a more recent version of OSX (El Captain) thanks to VirtualBox + Vagrant. With this I finally had the chance to address many long standing OSX bugs. Here's the list:
  • 514: fix Process.memory_maps() segfault (critical!).
  • 783: Process.status() may erroneously return "running" for zombie processes.
  • 908: different process methods could erroneously mask the real error for high-privileged PIDs and raise NoSuchProcess and AccessDenied instead of OSError and RuntimeError.
  • 909: Process open_files() and connections() methods may raise OSError with no exception set if process is gone.
  • 916: fix many compilation warnings.

Improved procinfo.py script

procinfo.py is a script which shows psutil capabilities regarding obtaining different info about processes. I improved it so that now it reports a lot more info. Here's a sample output:

$ python scripts/procinfo.py
pid           4600
name          chrome
parent        4554 (bash)
exe           /opt/google/chrome/chrome
cwd           /home/giampaolo
cmdline       /opt/google/chrome/chrome
started       2016-09-19 11:12
cpu-tspent    27:27.68
cpu-times     user=8914.32, system=3530.59,
              children_user=1.46, children_system=1.31
cpu-affinity  [0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7]
memory        rss=520.5M, vms=1.9G, shared=132.6M, text=95.0M, lib=0B,
              data=816.5M, dirty=0B
memory %      3.26
user          giampaolo
uids          real=1000, effective=1000, saved=1000
uids          real=1000, effective=1000, saved=1000
terminal      /dev/pts/2
status        sleeping
nice          0
ionice        class=IOPriority.IOPRIO_CLASS_NONE, value=0
num-threads   47
num-fds       379
I/O           read_count=96.6M, write_count=80.7M,
              read_bytes=293.2M, write_bytes=24.5G
ctx-switches  voluntary=30426463, involuntary=460108
children      PID    NAME
              4605   cat
              4606   cat
              4609   chrome
              4669   chrome
open-files    PATH
              /opt/google/chrome/icudtl.dat
              /opt/google/chrome/snapshot_blob.bin
              /opt/google/chrome/natives_blob.bin
              /opt/google/chrome/chrome_100_percent.pak
              [...]
connections   PROTO LOCAL ADDR            REMOTE ADDR               STATUS
              UDP   10.0.0.3:3693         *:*                       NONE
              TCP   10.0.0.3:55102        172.217.22.14:443         ESTABLISHED
              UDP   10.0.0.3:35172        *:*                       NONE
              TCP   10.0.0.3:32922        172.217.16.163:443        ESTABLISHED
              UDP   :::5353               *:*                       NONE
              UDP   10.0.0.3:59925        *:*                       NONE
threads       TID              USER          SYSTEM
              11795             0.7            1.35
              11796            0.68            1.37
              15887            0.74            0.03
              19055            0.77            0.01
              [...]
              total=47
res-limits    RLIMIT                     SOFT       HARD
              virtualmem             infinity   infinity
              coredumpsize                  0   infinity
              cputime                infinity   infinity
              datasize               infinity   infinity
              filesize               infinity   infinity
              locks                  infinity   infinity
              memlock                   65536      65536
              msgqueue                 819200     819200
              nice                          0          0
              openfiles                  8192      65536
              maxprocesses              63304      63304
              rss                    infinity   infinity
              realtimeprio                  0          0
              rtimesched             infinity   infinity
              sigspending               63304      63304
              stack                   8388608   infinity
mem-maps      RSS      PATH
              381.4M   [anon]
              62.8M    /opt/google/chrome/chrome
              15.8M    /home/giampaolo/.config/google-chrome/Default/History
              6.6M     /home/giampaolo/.config/google-chrome/Default/Favicons
              [...]

NIC netmask on Windows

net_if_addrs() on Windows is now able to return the netmask.

Other improvements and bug fixes

Just take a look at the HISTORY file.

Sunday, May 15, 2016

psutil 4.2.0, Windows services and Python

New psutil 4.2.0 is out. The main feature of this release is the support for Windows services:

>>> import psutil
>>> list(psutil.win_service_iter())
[<WindowsService(name='AeLookupSvc', display_name='Application Experience') at 38850096>,
 <WindowsService(name='ALG', display_name='Application Layer Gateway Service') at 38850128>,
 <WindowsService(name='APNMCP', display_name='Ask Update Service') at 38850160>,
 <WindowsService(name='AppIDSvc', display_name='Application Identity') at 38850192>,
 ...]
>>> s = psutil.win_service_get('alg')
>>> s.as_dict()
{'binpath': 'C:\\Windows\\System32\\alg.exe',
 'description': 'Provides support for 3rd party protocol plug-ins for Internet Connection Sharing',
 'display_name': 'Application Layer Gateway Service',
 'name': 'alg',
 'pid': None,
 'start_type': 'manual',
 'status': 'stopped',
 'username': 'NT AUTHORITY\\LocalService'}

I did this mainly because I find pywin32 APIs too low level. Having something like this in psutil can be useful to discover and monitor services more easily. The code changes are here and here's the doc. The API for querying a service is similar to psutil.Process. You can get a reference to a service object by using its name (which is unique for every service) and then use name(), status(), etc..:

>>> s = psutil.win_service_get('alg')
>>> s.name()
'alg'
>>> s.status()
'stopped'

Initially I thought to expose and provide a complete set of APIs to handle all aspects of service handling including start(), stop(), restart(), install(), uninstall() and modify() but I soon realized that I would have ended up reimplementing what pywin32 already provides at the cost of overcrowding psutil API (see my reasoning here). I think psutil should really be about monitoring, not about installing and modifying system stuff, especially something as critical as a Windows service.

Considerations about Windows services

For those of you who are not familiar with Windows, a service is something, generally an executable (.exe), which runs at system startup and keeps running in background. We can say they are the equivalent of a UNIX init script. All service are controlled by a "manager" which keeps track of their status and metadata (e.g. description, startup type) and with that you can start and stop them. It is interesting to note that since (most) services are bound to an executable (and hence a process) you can reference the process via its PID:

>>> s = psutil.win_service_get('sshd')
>>> s
<WindowsService(name='sshd', display_name='Open SSH server') at 38853046>
>>> s.pid()
1865
>>> p = psutil.Process(1865)
>>> p
<psutil.Process(pid=19547, name='sshd.exe') at 140461487781328>
>>> p.exe()
'C:\CygWin\bin\sshd'

Other improvements

psutil 4.2.0 comes with 2 other enhancements for Linux:
  • psutil.virtual_memory() returns a new "shared" memory field. This is the same value reported by "free" cmdline utility.
  • I changed the way how /proc was parsed. Instead of reading /proc/{pid}/status line by line I used a regular expression. Here's the speedups:
    * Process.ppid() is 20% faster
    * Process.status() is 28% faster
    * Process.name() is 25% faster
    * Process.num_threads() is 20% faster (on Python 3 only; on Python 2 it's a bit slower - I
       suppose re module received some improvements)

Links

Wednesday, February 17, 2016

psutil 4.0.0 and how to get "real" process memory and environ in Python

New psutil 4.0.0 is out, with some interesting news about process memory metrics. I'll just get straight to the point and describe what's new.

"Real" process memory info

Determining how much memory a process really uses is not an easy matter (see this and this). RSS (Resident Set Size), which is what most people usually rely on, is misleading because it includes both the memory which is unique to the process and the memory shared with other processes. What would be more interesting in terms of profiling is the memory which would be freed if the process was terminated right now. In the Linux world this is called USS (Unique Set Size), and this is the major feature which was introduced in psutil 4.0.0 (not only for Linux but also for Windows and OSX).

USS memory

The USS (Unique Set Size) is the memory which is unique to a process and which would be freed if the process was terminated right now. On Linux this can be determined by parsing all the "private" blocks in /proc/pid/smaps. The Firefox team pushed this further and managed to do the same also on OSX and Windows, which is great. New version of psutil is now able to do the same:
>>> psutil.Process().memory_full_info()
pfullmem(rss=101990, vms=521888, shared=38804, text=28200, lib=0, data=59672, dirty=0, 
         uss=81623, pss=91788, swap=0)

PSS and swap

On Linux there are two additional metrics which can also be determined via /proc/pid/smaps: PSS and swap. PSS, aka "Proportional Set Size", represents the amount of memory shared with other processes, accounted in a way that the amount is divided evenly between the processes that share it. I.e. if a process has 10 MBs all to itself (USS) and 10 MBs shared with another process, its PSS will be 15 MBs. "swap" is simply the amount of memory that has been swapped out to disk. With memory_full_info() it is possible to implement a tool like this, similar to smem on Linux, which provides a list of processes sorted by "USS". It is interesting to notice how RSS differs from USS:
~/svn/psutil$ ./scripts/procsmem.py
PID     User    Cmdline                            USS     PSS    Swap     RSS
==============================================================================
...
3986    giampao /usr/bin/python3 /usr/bin/indi   15.3M   16.6M      0B   25.6M
3906    giampao /usr/lib/ibus/ibus-ui-gtk3       17.6M   18.1M      0B   26.7M
3991    giampao python /usr/bin/hp-systray -x    19.0M   23.3M      0B   40.7M
3830    giampao /usr/bin/ibus-daemon --daemoni   19.0M   19.0M      0B   21.4M
20529   giampao /opt/sublime_text/plugin_host    19.9M   20.1M      0B   22.0M
3990    giampao nautilus -n                      20.6M   29.9M      0B   50.2M
3898    giampao /usr/lib/unity/unity-panel-ser   27.1M   27.9M      0B   37.7M
4176    giampao /usr/lib/evolution/evolution-c   35.7M   36.2M      0B   41.5M
20712   giampao /usr/bin/python -B /home/giamp   45.6M   45.9M      0B   49.4M
3880    giampao /usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/hud/   51.6M   52.7M      0B   61.3M
20513   giampao /opt/sublime_text/sublime_text   65.8M   73.0M      0B   87.9M
3976    giampao compiz                          115.0M  117.0M      0B  130.9M
32486   giampao skype                           145.1M  147.5M      0B  149.6M

Implementation

In order to get these values (USS, PSS and swap) we need to pass through the whole process address space. This usually requires higher user privileges and is considerably slower than getting the "usual" memory metrics via Process.memory_info(), which is probably the reason why tools like ps and top show RSS/VMS instead of USS. A big thanks goes to the Mozilla team which figured out all this stuff on Windows and OSX, and to Eric Rahm who put the PRs for psutil together (see #744, #745 and #746). For those of you who don't use Python and would like to port the code on other languages here's the interesting parts:

Memory type percent

After reorganizing process memory APIs I decided to add a new memtype parameter to Process.memory_percent(). With this it is now possible to compare a specific memory type (not only RSS) against the total physical memory. E.g.
>>> psutil.Process().memory_percent(memtype='pss')
0.06877466326787016

Process environ

Second biggest improvement in psutil 4.0.0 is the ability to determine the process environment variables. This opens interesting possibilities about process recognition and monitoring techniques. For instance, one might start a process by passing a certain custom environment variable, then iterate over all processes to find the one of interest (and figure out whether it's running or whatever):
import psutil
for p in psutil.process_iter():
    try:
        env = p.environ()
    except psutil.Error:
        pass
    else:
        if 'MYAPP' in env:
            ...
Process environ was a long standing issue (year 2009) who I gave up to implement because the Windows implementation worked for the current process only. Frank Benkstein solved that and the process environ can now be determined on Linux, Windows and OSX for all processes (of course you may still bump into AccessDenied for processes owned by another user):
>>> import psutil
>>> from pprint import pprint as pp
>>> pp(psutil.Process().environ())
{...
 'CLUTTER_IM_MODULE': 'xim',
 'COLORTERM': 'gnome-terminal',
 'COMPIZ_BIN_PATH': '/usr/bin/',
 'HOME': '/home/giampaolo',
 'PWD': '/home/giampaolo/svn/psutil',
  }
>>>
It must be noted that the resulting dict usually does not reflect changes made after the process started (e.g. os.environ['MYAPP'] = '1'). Again, for whoever is interested in doing this in other languages, here's the interesting parts:

Extended disk IO stats

psutil.disk_io_counters() has been extended to report additional metrics on Linux and FreeBSD:
  • busy_time, which is the time spent doing actual I/Os (in milliseconds).
  • read_merged_count and write_merged_count (Linux only), which is number of merged reads and writes (see iostats doc)
With these new metrics it is possible to have a better representation of actual disk utilization, similarly to iostat command on Linux.

OS constants

Given the increasing number of platform-specific metrics I added a new set of constants to quickly differentiate what platform you're on: psutil.LINUX, psutil.WINDOWS, etc.

Main bug fixes


  • #734: on Python 3 invalid UTF-8 data was not correctly handled for proces name(), cwd(), exe(), cmdline() and open_files() methods, resulting in UnicodeDecodeError. This was affecting all platforms. Now surrogateescape error handler is used as a workaround for replacing the corrupted data.
  • #761: [Windows] psutil.boot_time() no longer wraps to 0 after 49 days.
  • #767: [Linux] disk_io_counters() may raise ValueError on 2.6 kernels and it's  broken on 2.4 kernels.
  • #764: psutil can now be compiled on NetBSD-6.X.
  • #704: psutil can now be compiled on Solaris sparc.
Complete list of bug fixes is available here.

Porting code

Being 4.0.0 a major version, I took the chance to (lightly) change / break some APIs.
  • Process.memory_info() no longer returns just an (rss, vms) namedtuple. Instead it returns a namedtuple of variable length, changing depending on the platform (rss and vms are always present though, also on Windows). Basically it returns the same result of old process_memory_info_ex(). This shouldn't break your existent code, unless you were doing "rss, vms = p.memory_info()".
  • At the same time process_memory_info_ex() is now deprecated. The method is still there as an alias for memory_info(), issuing a deprecation warning.
  • psutil.disk_io_counters() returns 2 additional fields on Linux and 1 additional field on FreeBSD. 
  • psutil.disk_io_counters() on NetBSD and OpenBSD no longer return write_count and read_count metrics because the kernel do not provide them (we were returning the busy time instead). I also don't expect this to be a big issue because NetBSD and OpenBSD support is very recent.

Final notes and looking for a job

OK, this is it. I would like to spend a couple more words to announce the world that I'm currently unemployed and looking for a remote gig again! =) I want remote because my plan for this year is to remain in Prague (Czech Republic) and possibly spend 2-3 months in Asia. If you know about any company who's looking for a Python backend dev who can work from afar feel free to share my Linkedin profile or mail me at g.rodola [at] gmail [dot] com.

External links

Friday, February 12, 2016

How to always execute exit functions in Python

...or why atexit.register() and signal.signal() are evil

UPDATE (2016-02-13): this recipe no longer handles SIGINT, SIGQUIT and SIGABRT as aliases for "application exit" because it was a bad idea. It only handles SIGTERM. Also it no longer support Windows because signal.signal() implementation is too different than POSIX.

Many people erroneously think that any function registered via atexit module is guaranteed to always be executed when the program terminates. You may have noticed this is not the case when, for example, you daemonize your app in production then try to stop it or restart it: the cleanup functions will not be executed. This is because functions registered wth atexit module are not called when the program is killed by a signal:
import atexit, os, signal

@atexit.register
def cleanup():
    print("on exit")  # XXX this never gets printed

os.kill(os.getpid(), signal.SIGTERM)

It must be noted that the same thing would happen if instead of atexit.register() we would use a "finally" clause. It turns out the correct way to make sure the exit function is always called in case a signal is received is to register it via signal.signal(). That has a drawback though: in case a third-party module has already registered a function for that signal (SIGTERM or whatever), your new function will overwrite the old one:

import os, signal

def old(*args):
    print("old")  # XXX this never gets printed

def new(*args):
    print("new")

signal.signal(signal.SIGTERM, old)
signal.signal(signal.SIGTERM, new)
os.kill(os.getpid(), signal.SIGTERM)

Also, we would still have to use atexit.register() so that the function is called also on "clean" interpreter exit and take into account other signals other than SIGTERM which would cause the process to terminate. This recipe attempts to address all these issues so that:
  •  the exit function is always executed for all exit signals (SIGTERM, SIGINT, SIGQUIT, SIGABRT) on SIGTERM and on "clean" interpreter exit.
  • any exit function(s) previously registered via atexit.register() or signal.signal() will be executed as well (after the new one). 
  • It must be noted that the exit function will never be executed in case of SIGKILL, SIGSTOP or os._exit().

The code

"""
Function / decorator which tries very hard to register a function to
be executed at importerer exit.

Author: Giampaolo Rodola'
License: MIT
"""

from __future__ import print_function
import atexit
import os
import functools
import signal
import sys


_registered_exit_funs = set()
_executed_exit_funs = set()


def register_exit_fun(fun=None, signals=[signal.SIGTERM],
                      logfun=lambda s: print(s, file=sys.stderr)):
    """Register a function which will be executed on "normal"
    interpreter exit or in case one of the `signals` is received
    by this process (differently from atexit.register()).
    Also, it makes sure to execute any other function which was
    previously registered via signal.signal(). If any, it will be
    executed after our own `fun`.

    Functions which were already registered or executed via this
    function will be ignored.

    Note: there's no way to escape SIGKILL, SIGSTOP or os._exit(0)
    so don't bother trying.

    You can use this either as a function or as a decorator:

        @register_exit_fun
        def cleanup():
            pass

        # ...or

        register_exit_fun(cleanup)

    Note about Windows: I tested this some time ago and didn't work
    exactly the same as on UNIX, then I didn't care about it
    anymore and didn't test since then so may not work on Windows.

    Parameters:

    - fun: a callable
    - signals: a list of signals for which this function will be
      executed (default SIGTERM)
    - logfun: a logging function which is called when a signal is
      received. Default: print to standard error. May be set to
      None if no logging is desired.
    """
    def stringify_sig(signum):
        if sys.version_info < (3, 5):
            smap = dict([(getattr(signal, x), x) for x in dir(signal)
                         if x.startswith('SIG')])
            return smap.get(signum, signum)
        else:
            return signum

    def fun_wrapper():
        if fun not in _executed_exit_funs:
            try:
                fun()
            finally:
                _executed_exit_funs.add(fun)

    def signal_wrapper(signum=None, frame=None):
        if signum is not None:
            if logfun is not None:
                logfun("signal {} received by process with PID {}".format(
                    stringify_sig(signum), os.getpid()))
        fun_wrapper()
        # Only return the original signal this process was hit with
        # in case fun returns with no errors, otherwise process will
        # return with sig 1.
        if signum is not None:
            if signum == signal.SIGINT:
                raise KeyboardInterrupt
            # XXX - should we do the same for SIGTERM / SystemExit?
            sys.exit(signum)

    def register_fun(fun, signals):
        if not callable(fun):
            raise TypeError("{!r} is not callable".format(fun))
        set([fun])  # raise exc if obj is not hash-able

        signals = set(signals)
        for sig in signals:
            # Register function for this signal and pop() the previously
            # registered one (if any). This can either be a callable,
            # SIG_IGN (ignore signal) or SIG_DFL (perform default action
            # for signal).
            old_handler = signal.signal(sig, signal_wrapper)
            if old_handler not in (signal.SIG_DFL, signal.SIG_IGN):
                # ...just for extra safety.
                if not callable(old_handler):
                    continue
                # This is needed otherwise we'll get a KeyboardInterrupt
                # strace on interpreter exit, even if the process exited
                # with sig 0.
                if (sig == signal.SIGINT and
                        old_handler is signal.default_int_handler):
                    continue
                # There was a function which was already registered for this
                # signal. Register it again so it will get executed (after our
                # new fun).
                if old_handler not in _registered_exit_funs:
                    atexit.register(old_handler)
                    _registered_exit_funs.add(old_handler)

        # This further registration will be executed in case of clean
        # interpreter exit (no signals received).
        if fun not in _registered_exit_funs or not signals:
            atexit.register(fun_wrapper)
            _registered_exit_funs.add(fun)

    # This piece of machinery handles 3 usage cases. register_exit_fun()
    # used as:
    # - a function
    # - a decorator without parentheses
    # - a decorator with parentheses
    if fun is None:
        @functools.wraps
        def outer(fun):
            return register_fun(fun, signals)
        return outer
    else:
        register_fun(fun, signals)
        return fun

Usage

As a function:
def cleanup():
    print("cleanup")

register_exit_fun(cleanup)
As a decorator:
@register_exit_fun
def cleanup():
    print("cleanup")

Unit tests

This recipe is hosted on ActiveState and has a full set of unittests. It works with Python 2 and 3.

Notes about Windows

On Windows signals are only partially supported meaning a function which was previously registered via signal.signal() will be executed only on interpreter exit, but not if the process receives a signal. Apparently this is a limitation either of Windows or the signal module (most likely Windows).

Because of how different signal.signal() behaves on Windows, this code is UNIX only: http://bugs.python.org/issue26350

Proposal for stdlib inclusion

The fact that atexit module does not handle signals and that signal.signal() overwrites previously registered handlers is unfortunate. It is also confusing because it is not immediately clear which one you are supposed to use (and it turns out you're supposed to use both). Most of the times you have no idea (or don't care) that you're overwriting another exit function. As a user, I would just want to execute an exit function, no matter what, possibly without messing with whatever a module I've previously imported has done with signal.signal(). To me this suggests there could be space for something like "atexit.register_w_signals".

External discussions

Friday, January 15, 2016

NetBSD support for psutil

Roughly two months have passed since I last announced psutil added support for OpenBSD platforms. Today I am happy to announce we also have NetBSD support! This was contributed by Thomas KlausnerRyo Onodera and myself in PR #570.

Differences with FreeBSD (and OpenBSD)

NetBSD implementation has similar limitations as the ones I encountered with OpenBSD. Again, FreeBSD presents itself as the BSD variant with the best support in terms of kernel functionalities.
As for the rest: it is all there. All memory, disk, network and process APIs are fully supported and functioning.

Other enhancements available in this psutil release

Other than NetBSD support this new release has a couple of interesting enhancements:

  • #708: [Linux] psutil.net_connections() and Process.connections() on Python can be up to 3x faster in case of many connections.
  • #718: process_iter() is now thread safe.
You can read the rest in the HISTORY file, as usual.

Move to Prague

As a personal note I'd like to add that I'm currently in Prague (Czech Republic) and I'm thinking about moving down here for a while. The city is great and girls are beautiful. ;-)

External discussions

Tuesday, November 24, 2015

OpenBSD support for psutil

OK, this is a big one: starting from version 3.3.0 (released just now) psutil will officially support OpenBSD platforms. This was contributed by Landry Breuil (thanks dude!) and myself in PR #615. The interesting parts of the code changes are this and this.

Differences with FreeBSD

As expected, OpenBSD implementation is very similar to FreeBSD's (which was already in place), that is why I decided to merge most of it in a single C file (_psutil_bsd.c) and use 2 separate C files for when the two implementations differed too much: freebsd.c and openbsd.c. In terms of functionality here's the differences with FreeBSD. Unless specified, these differences are due to the kernel which does not provide the information natively (meaning we can't do anything about it).
Similarly to FreeBSD, also OpenBSD implementation of Process.open_files() is problematic as it is not able to return file paths (FreeBSD can sometimes). Other than these differences the functionalities are all there and pretty much the same, so overall I'm pretty satisfied with the result. 

Considerations about BSD platforms

psutil has been supporting FreeBSD basically since the beginning (year 2009). At the time it made sense to support FreeBSD instead of other BSD variants because it is the most popular, followed by OpenBSD and NetBSD. Compared to FreeBSD, OpenBSD appears to be more "minimal" both in terms of facilities provided by the kernel and the number of system administration tools available. One thing which I appreciate a lot about FreeBSD is that the source code of all CLI tools installed on the system is available under /usr/bin/src, which was a big help for implementing all psutil APIs. OpenBSD source code is also available but it uses CSV and I am not sure it includes the source code for all CLI tools. There are still two more BSD variants for which it may be worth to add support for: NetBSD and DragonflyBSD (in this order). About a year ago some guy provided a patch for adding basic NetBSD support so it is likely that will happen sooner or later.

Other enhancements available in this release

The only other enhancement is issue #558, which allows specifying a different location of /proc filesystem on Linux.

External discussions